GINN ECONOMIC CONSULTING
  • Home
  • Work
  • SERVICES
  • Speaking
  • Media
  • PUBLICATIONS
  • About
  • Home
  • Work
  • SERVICES
  • Speaking
  • Media
  • PUBLICATIONS
  • About

Texas: A Leader in Tax Competitiveness, But Room to Improve

12/17/2024

0 Comments

 
Picture
Originally posted at Texans for Fiscal Responsibility.

​Texas ranks 7th in the 2025 State Tax Competitiveness Index, benefiting from its lack of an individual income tax and a competitive unemployment insurance tax system. However, high property taxes, a complex corporate tax system, and excessive government spending, all help to prevent Texas from reaching the top spot. With millions of people and businesses relocating to Texas, the state has a unique opportunity in the 89th Legislative Session to solidify its position as the economic leader by addressing these three key challenges.
Picture
​What Is the State Tax Competitiveness Index?
The State Tax Competitiveness Index, formerly known as the State Business Tax Climate Index, evaluates how effectively states design their tax systems. It ranks states based on five key categories:
  • Corporate Taxes
  • Individual Income Taxes
  • Sales Taxes
  • Property Taxes
  • Unemployment Insurance Taxes

States with transparent, low-rate, and neutral tax systems perform best in the index. 

Top Five Overall States 
  1. Wyoming
  2. South Dakota
  3. Alaska
  4. Florida 
  5. Montana 
​
Texas excels in individual income taxes (ranked 1st due to having no tax) and unemployment insurance taxes (ranked 30th), but its rankings in other areas, particularly property taxes and corporate taxes, highlight significant room for improvement.
Picture
​While Texas outperforms neighboring states in overall competitiveness, high property tax burdens and a low corporate tax ranking highlight significant barriers to achieving the top spot.

Addressing the Property Tax Challenge
Texas ranks 40th in property tax competitiveness, primarily due to its heavy reliance on local property taxes to fund public services. Local governments impose some of the highest property tax rates in the nation, with school district maintenance and operations (M&O) property taxes comprising nearly half of total property tax collections. 

Recent reforms provide some relief but fail to address systemic issues. To achieve meaningful property tax relief, Texas must use its state budget surplus to buy down school district M&O property tax rates, aiming to eliminate them in about a decade. This approach ensures sustainable relief without compromising funding for essential services.

Reforming the Corporate Tax System
Texas’s gross receipts tax, known as the business franchise or margin tax, ranks 46th in corporate tax competitiveness. This tax applies to gross revenues rather than net profits, making it especially burdensome for businesses with low-profit margins. Phasing out the margin tax would simplify the corporate tax system, attract investment, and improve Texas’s competitiveness.

Spending Restraint: The Foundation for Sustainable Reform
Unchecked government spending is the root cause of Texas’s tax challenges. As TFR’s Frozen Texas Budget outlines, excessive state and local spending drives high property taxes and undermines long-term prosperity. 
To address this, Texas must adopt constitutional spending limits with a maximum rate of population gr
owth plus inflation at both the state and local levels, but there is a need for spending cuts in the near term to correct past excesses. This disciplined approach prevents budget bloat and ensures that fiscal deficits or future tax hikes do not follow tax reductions.

Strategic Recommendations for Texas Policymakers
  1. Adopt Strong Spending Limits: Cap all state and local government spending growth to population growth plus inflation (as an absolute maximum) to ensure fiscal sustainability.
  2. Use Surplus to Buy Down Property Taxes: Dedicate surplus revenues to phasing out school district M&O property taxes, providing long-term relief to homeowners and businesses alike.
  3. Eliminate the Margin Tax: Phase out the gross receipts tax to simplify corporate taxation and enhance competitiveness.
  4. Reform Sales and Property Taxes: Streamline the sales tax system and explore alternatives to high property tax reliance for local government funding.

The Path Forward
Texas is well-positioned to lead the nation in economic competitiveness, but achieving the top spot in the State Tax Competitiveness Index requires bold action. Texas can attract even more businesses and residents by prioritizing property tax relief, corporate tax reform, and spending restraint while fostering a thriving, dynamic economy.
0 Comments

Congress Must Act to Cut Government Spending: Vance Ginn Explains on NTD News

12/17/2024

0 Comments

 
​Despite cooling inflation, consumer sentiment is still low as its impact continues to weigh on households.

Vance Ginn, president of Ginn Economic Consulting and former chief economist of the Office of Management and Budget, spoke to NTD about the future of the American economy in the next four years.

Here's the post by NTD News: https://www.ntd.com/congress-must-act-to-cut-government-spending-economist_1034926.html
0 Comments

If More Money Isn’t The Answer, What Will Truly Fix The Education System: Lars Larson Show

12/17/2024

0 Comments

 
Picture
Listen here to my interview on The Lars Larson Show. 
0 Comments

Kansas’s Economic Freedom: Navigating Challenges and Opportunities

12/16/2024

0 Comments

 
Picture
Originally published at Kansas Policy Institute. 

​Kansas ranks 14th in the 2024 Economic Freedom of North America (EFNA) report, reflecting an above-average position among U.S. states. To improve, Kansas must address problems in its tax structure and government spending while leveraging its strengths to catch up with leading states like Florida (3rd), Tennessee (4th), and Texas (5).

Neighboring States: How Kansas Stacks Up
​
Kansas is surrounded by states with varying degrees of economic freedom, offering both inspiration and a competitive benchmark:
  • Oklahoma (11th): Pro-growth policies, lean government, and low taxes.
  • Nebraska (13th): Fiscal reforms and competitive taxes drive its strengths.
  • Colorado (14th): Above average economic freedom but hampered by rising regulations and tax pressures.
  • Missouri (17th): Balanced tax structure and disciplined state spending.
Picture
​Compared to these neighbors, Kansas’s ranking is respectable, but it highlights opportunities for improvement, particularly in areas like taxation and government spending.

Taxation: Challenges and Opportunities
Kansas’s tax system remains a weak point, as highlighted by its 25th-place ranking in the Tax Foundation’s 2025 State Business Tax Climate Index.
  • Corporate Taxes: While Kansas has improved, burdensome provisions like the throwback rule hurt business competitiveness.
  • Individual Income Taxes: Kansas’s top rate of 5.7% is high compared to Oklahoma (4.75%) and Texas, which has no state income tax.
  • Property Taxes: Kansas has one of the highest property tax burdens in the region, discouraging investment and homeownership.
To remain competitive, Kansas must simplify its tax structure, reduce income and property tax rates, and eliminate counterproductive provisions like the throwback rule.

Government Spending: Curbing Growth
Excessive government spending continues to weigh on Kansas’s economic freedom. Over the years, state appropriations have outpaced population growth and inflation, creating fiscal strain and driving higher taxes. For example, if Kansas’s spending since 2005 had been limited to these benchmarks, its budget would be $6.7 billion lower today.

To address this, Kansas should implement stricter spending caps and adopt priority-based budgeting to ensure taxpayer dollars are used efficiently. Redirecting savings toward tax reductions would create a more sustainable fiscal environment and reduce the burden on residents and businesses.

Labor Market Regulations: A Mixed Bag
Kansas ranks 23rd in labor market freedom, reflecting strengths in right-to-work policies and relatively low union influence. However, burdensome occupational licensing laws remain a barrier to workforce mobility and entrepreneurship.

Simplifying licensing requirements and expanding reciprocity agreements with other states would attract skilled workers and help Kansas build a more dynamic workforce. This is especially important for low-income residents seeking upward mobility.

How Kansas Can Improve
Kansas has the potential to rise in economic freedom rankings with targeted reforms. Key priorities include:
  • Lower Taxes: Simplify the tax code, reduce property and income taxes, and eliminate the throwback rule to make the state more competitive.
  • Control Spending: Implement spending caps tied to population growth and inflation and expand priority-based budgeting to reduce waste and ensure fiscal sustainability.
  • Reform Licensing Laws: Streamline occupational licensing requirements and increase reciprocity agreements to enhance workforce flexibility and job creation.

Conclusion
Kansas has made progress in economic freedom, but challenges in taxation and government spending hinder its potential. By learning from its neighbors and addressing inefficiencies, Kansas can strengthen its position and attract more businesses, residents, and investment.
​

The path forward is clear: lower taxes, control spending, and reduce barriers to work. By taking these steps, Kansas can lead the region in economic freedom and secure long-term prosperity for its people.
0 Comments

Economy Shifts: Fed Cuts, Tax Moves, and TikTok Ban | This Week's Economy Ep. 91

12/16/2024

0 Comments

 
​Welcome to This Week’s Economy podcast! In this episode, we explore the Federal Reserve’s interest rate decision, President-elect Trump’s ambitious early agenda, the potential fallout from a looming TikTok ban, and new state tax competitiveness rankings. Join me as I unpack these pivotal developments, their economic implications, and the actions needed to secure prosperity for all Americans. Watch the episode on YouTube below, listen to it on Apple Podcast or Spotify, and visit my website for more information.
0 Comments

Why Texas Needs Universal School Choice

12/16/2024

0 Comments

 
Picture
Originally posted on X. 

​Despite a 42% increase in per-student education funding since 2011 in Texas, 8th-grade math proficiency has dropped by 40%. 

As administrative costs and bureaucracy grow, less than half of education funding reaches teachers. This is not a teacher problem; it’s a system problem. The current government school monopoly prioritizes funding systems over outcomes, leaving too many students behind. 

The solution is clear: universal school choice through Education Savings Accounts (ESAs).

For decades, the status quo has relied on a rigid, state-determined school finance formula. Taxpayer dollars are funneled into district-zoned public schools, regardless of whether those schools meet students' needs. Families are left with no flexibility, trapped by zip codes, and forced into a one-size-fits-all system. 

While there are success stories, the overall picture is bleak, particularly for underserved communities. The incentives are broken, and the system has little reason to innovate or improve without competition or accountability. Texas families deserve better.

Some argue that vouchers are a sufficient solution. While they expand access to private schools by providing families with a set amount of funding for tuition, vouchers fall short in several ways. They often come with government-imposed regulations that stifle innovation in private schools, and they focus narrowly on tuition, excluding other educational expenses like tutoring, transportation, therapy, or homeschool resources.

This is where Education Savings Accounts stand apart. ESAs give parents control of the funding, which they can use for various approved educational expenses. Whether at a traditional "public" school, charter school, private school tuition, specialized therapy, transportation, tutoring, or homeschool materials, ESAs allow families to build a customized education for their child. 

Unlike vouchers, ESAs empower parents to design an education plan that fits their child’s specific needs, ensuring a student-centered approach.

Critics often claim ESAs will harm public schools, but this fear is unfounded. 

First, public schools will remain an option for families who prefer them. ESAs do not dismantle public education; they introduce competition and give families a choice. 

Second, ESAs save taxpayers money. A universal ESA program in Texas could save nearly $20 billion annually, per my recent article with @brianeharrison in the @dallasnews. 

These savings would provide a significant down payment to cut two-thirds of ISD maintenance and operations (M&O) property taxes, putting Texas on a path toward eliminating them. 

That’s real relief for families while ensuring parents spend taxpayer dollars for improved student outcomes.

The monopoly school model incentivizes maintaining the system over serving students. By introducing competition through ESAs, public or private schools must innovate and deliver value to attract and retain students. 

This realignment of incentives encourages efficiency, improves outcomes, and shifts resources where they are needed most: in the classroom. Teachers, who are often underpaid and undervalued, will also benefit. By reducing administrative bloat and prioritizing funding for classrooms, ESAs can lead to higher teacher salaries and more support for their critical work.

Some opponents suggest that local control is the answer, arguing that the state should get out of the way and let districts innovate. 

While local control is a worthy principle, public schools are constrained by state and federal mandates, making it practically impossible under the current framework. ESAs, by contrast, empower families directly, providing ultimate local control, removing bureaucratic barriers, and giving them the freedom to choose what works best for their children.

The critics of universal school choice often resort to fearmongering, claiming that ESAs will devastate public schools or leave certain students behind. But the data and experience from other states with similar programs tell a different story. 
Over 30 states have some form of school choice, and more than 10 states have implemented universal or near-universal ESAs. Public schools can and do thrive in competitive environments. Families who are satisfied with their local public school can stay, while those who need other options finally have a chance to find the right fit. 

ESAs don’t take away choice—they expand it.

Texas has a chance to lead the nation in putting students first. By adopting universal school choice through Education Savings Accounts, we can empower families, improve outcomes, save taxpayers billions, and reduce the crushing burden of property taxes. 

The current system has had decades to prove itself, and the results are clear: it’s not working for too many students. It’s time to fund students, not systems. Let’s build an education model that values every child’s potential and delivers on the promise of opportunity for all Texans.
0 Comments

Trump’s ex-OMB economic advisor wants less tariffs, more agreements with US allies will force China to change trade practices

12/13/2024

0 Comments

 
Picture
Listen here!

On this episode of the podcast, Vance Ginn, former Trump White House economic advisor, dives into the pressing economic challenges facing the new Trump administration and offers solutions rooted in pro-growth policies. Ginn outlines strategies to curb inflation and address the staggering $36 trillion national debt, emphasizing the need to cut government spending, implement tax reform, deregulate industries, and pursue free trade agreements. The former Office of Management and Budget Chief Economist also evaluates the impact of Trump’s plans to impose new tariffs, the effectiveness of Trump-era tax cuts, and the Department of Government Efficiency's role in reducing wasteful spending. Ginn makes a bold case for eliminating the federal minimum wage to foster competition and create new jobs.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
0 Comments

Third-Party Voices: Antidote to Bipartisan Big Government Drift?

12/13/2024

0 Comments

 
Picture
Originally posted at X. 

Imagine a government where big government doesn't burden your future with excessive spending, taxes, and regulations. Here's how...

The 2024 election showcased a familiar spectacle: @GOP and @TheDemocrats clinging to power while ignoring America's mounting fiscal and economic crises. With unified Republican control starting January 2025 under President-elect
@realDonaldTrump, there's optimism for change. But history is a stern teacher—both parties have repeatedly failed to embrace the free-market reforms needed to address runaway debt, inflation, and overregulation.

If you're like me and tired of the same old political tune, third parties might be the new harmony we need.
Leaders like @LPNational @ChaseForLiberty, Independent @RobertfKennedJr, and outsiders like @elonmusk and @VivekGRamaswamy challenge the entrenched status quo. They offer critiques of the bipartisan failure to rein in government overreach, promoting a return to limited government, fiscal responsibility, and the principles of free-market capitalism.

America's fiscal mess is a bipartisan failure. With a national debt soaring past $36 trillion, both parties are complicit in this addiction to spending. Fiscal irresponsibility and Federal Reserve intervention drive inflation, which erodes our purchasing power. Regulatory bloat stifles innovation. A recent @pewresearch poll reveals that 60% of Americans want a smaller government, yet neither party has delivered.

Will Trump seize the opportunity for pro-growth reforms, or will he veer towards protectionism, populism, and progressive policies from the "New Right"?

Republicans once championed fiscal restraint but now flirt with protectionism and interventionism. Democrats double down on expansive welfare and regulations, inching us towards socialism. Trump can reverse this trend, but will he take it? His approach could either heal or further deepen our economic woes.

Third-party candidates and independents are the catalysts for reform, providing a counterweight to this drift. They challenge the sacred cows of Washington politics with ideas grounded in liberty, sustainability, and economic opportunity. For instance, Chase Oliver advocates fiscal discipline, such as Colorado's TABOR, which could anchor federal spending to taxpayers' interests. Similarly, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. pushed for healthcare reforms that empower individuals, rejecting federal overreach.

Key reforms to reverse this trend include:
  • Ending corporate welfare, including the green energy scheme, to save billions and foster competition.
  • Reforming mandatory spending programs like Social Security and Medicare with private accounts, means testing, and age adjustments.
  • Adopting fiscal restraints like Colorado's TABOR to impose discipline on Congress.
  • Promoting free trade, especially with our allies, will lower prices and boost innovation, countering the current trend of protectionism.
  • Simplifying the tax code and cutting taxes for economic growth.
The choice is stark: embrace these reforms or continue the slide towards socialism.

With control in Washington, Trump and the GOP must decide whether to champion limited government and market-based reforms or perpetuate the status quo. They could look to independent thinkers for inspiration and embrace bold proposals to reduce spending, empower individuals, and restore free-market capitalism.

The future of America hinges on rejecting the failed policies of government expansion. By prioritizing fiscal restraint, deregulation, and individual liberty, Republicans can lead the nation away from socialism's grip and toward reviving free-market principles. Third-party voices, often sidelined, hold the keys to this vision.

Time will tell if Trump uses his influence for a pro-growth agenda or opts for a more populist, protectionist path. Which will it be? ​
0 Comments

The Future of Energy Abundance with Josh T. Smith | Let People Prosper Show Ep. 126

12/12/2024

0 Comments

 
In this episode of Let People Prosper, Vance Ginn dives deep into the complexities of energy markets with Josh T. Smith, energy policy lead at the Abundance Institute and author of the Substack newsletter . We explore the barriers and opportunities in energy policy, the role of permitting reforms, and the importance of innovation in achieving energy abundance. Josh shares how the Abundance Institute is paving the way for new energy technologies and why collaboration and market-based solutions are key to a prosperous energy future.

(0:00) - Introduction to Energy Markets and MotivationJosh shares his passion for influencing energy policy and the challenges he sees in the current landscape.
(6:04) - The Abundance Institute and Its MissionThe institute’s focus on creating pathways for new energy technologies and fostering innovation through policy and networking.
(11:56) - Federal Energy Policy ChallengesDiscussion on the barriers created by subsidies and the importance of addressing permitting reform to facilitate energy development.
(17:56) - Future of Energy Production and InterconnectionExploring the complexities of the interconnection process and the potential of modular nuclear reactors.
(24:41) - Reliability and System-Level Attributes in EnergyWhy reliability is crucial for energy systems and how market-driven solutions can improve it.
(31:43) - Innovations in Energy: Nuclear and BeyondThe role of cutting-edge technologies and behind-the-meter innovations in shaping the future of energy production.​
0 Comments

Louisiana’s Tax Competitiveness Poised for Improvement

12/11/2024

0 Comments

 
Picture
Originally published at Pelican Institute. 

​Louisiana ranks 40th in the 2025 State Tax Competitiveness Index, reflecting its historically complex and burdensome tax system. However, sweeping tax reforms enacted in 2024 are set to improve its ranking significantly in future reports. These reforms, which simplify income taxes, eliminate the business franchise tax, and address key structural challenges, mark a major step forward. Yet, to ensure these gains are sustainable, Louisiana must embrace spending restraint and use surplus revenues to further reduce and eventually eliminate income taxes.
Picture
​What Is the State Tax Competitiveness Index?
​
The State Tax Competitiveness Index, formerly the State Business Tax Climate Index, measures how well states structure their tax systems. It evaluates five key areas: corporate taxes, individual income taxes, sales taxes, property taxes, and unemployment insurance taxes. States that rank highest have tax systems that are simple, transparent, and designed to minimize economic distortions. Louisiana’s low ranking has long been driven by its high combined sales tax rates, punitive inventory taxes, and a franchise tax that penalized investment. The following tables show the rankings for Louisiana by tax category and compare them with those of other states.
Picture
​Top Overall States
  • #1 Wyoming
  • #2 South Dakota
  • #3 Alaska
  • #4 Florida
  • #5 Montana

Bottom Overall States
  • #50 New York
  • #49 New Jersey
  • #48 California
  • #48 District of Columbia
  • #47 Connecticut

Neighboring States
  • #7 Texas
  • #27 Mississippi
  • #36 Arkansas

Transformative 2024 Tax Reforms
The 2024 tax reforms during a special session called by Louisiana Governor Jeff Landry addressed several of these issues, creating a foundation for improved competitiveness:
  • Elimination of the Business Franchise Tax: This long-overdue reform removes a major obstacle to investment and economic growth by ending a tax that applied to businesses regardless of profitability.
  • Simplified Personal Income Tax: Louisiana now has a flat 3% income tax rate, the second-lowest among states with an income tax. This rate is paired with a standard deduction of $12,500 for individuals and $25,000 for couples, making the system simpler and more competitive.
  • Streamlined Corporate Income Tax: The state replaced its graduated corporate tax structure with a flat 5.5% rate and added a $20,000 standard deduction, aligning with best practices for attracting business investment.
  • Broader Sales Tax Base: By broadening the sales tax to include digital goods and services and maintaining a 5% state sales tax, Louisiana improved its revenue base while still contending with one of the nation’s highest combined sales tax rates.

These reforms will likely raise Louisiana’s ranking in the 2026 State Tax Competitiveness Index, closing the gap with states like Texas and Florida, which do not have income taxes.

The Role of Spending Restraint
While these tax changes represent meaningful progress, they will only deliver sustainable benefits if accompanied by spending discipline. Louisiana can use its current surplus to buy down income tax rates further and eventually eliminate them.

Adopting a fiscally conservative framework would prevent unsustainable budget expansions and allow tax relief to last. Spending restraint ensures that tax reductions are not followed by future tax hikes, preserving Louisiana’s competitiveness in the long term.

Recommendations for Bold Progress
  1. Adopt Spending Caps: Constitutionally limit government growth to no more than population growth plus inflation, ensuring fiscal stability.
  2. Use Surplus to Phase Out Income Taxes: Dedicate surplus revenues to reducing and eventually eliminating personal and corporate income taxes, putting Louisiana on par with no-income-tax states.
  3. Streamline Sales and Property Taxes: Simplify the sales tax system and eliminate inventory taxes to encourage investment and reduce compliance costs.
  4. Prioritize Fiscal Discipline: Avoid unnecessary spending increases and focus on policies that promote economic freedom and growth.
The Pelican State’s Opportunity
The 2024 tax reforms provide Louisiana with a transformative opportunity to overhaul its economic trajectory. These changes simplify the tax code, improve business competitiveness, and set the stage for Louisiana to rise in future editions of the State Tax Competitiveness Index.
​
To fully capitalize on these gains, Louisiana must pair its tax reforms with strong spending restraint and use its surplus strategically to phase out income taxes. By doing so, the Pelican State can emerge as a leader in economic growth and competitiveness, attracting businesses, residents, and investment.
0 Comments
<<Previous
Forward>>

    Vance Ginn, Ph.D.
    ​@LetPeopleProsper

    Vance Ginn, Ph.D., is President of Ginn Economic Consulting and collaborates with more than 20 free-market think tanks to let people prosper. Follow him on X: @vanceginn, and subscribe to his newsletter: vanceginn.substack.com

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Categories

    All
    Affordability
    Antitrust
    Banking
    Biden
    Book
    Book Reviews
    Budgets
    Capitalism
    Carbon Tax
    China
    Commentary
    Congress
    COVID
    Debt
    Economic Freedom
    Economy
    Education
    Energy Markets
    Fed
    Free Trade
    Ginn Economic Brief
    Healthcare
    Housing
    Immigration
    Inflation
    Interview
    Jobs Report
    Kansas
    Let People Prosper
    Licensing
    Louisiana
    Medicaid
    Medicare
    Minimum Wage
    Occupational Licensing
    Pensions
    Policy Guide
    Poverty
    Price Control
    Property Taxes
    Regulation
    Research
    School Choice
    Socialism
    Speech
    Spending Limits
    Taxes
    Technology
    Testimony
    Texas
    This Week's Economy
    Transparency
    Trump

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly